The Murder of Laura Foster

[Finding information on Edith Carter is proving to be difficult. The name is common in the United Kingdom and the American south. In a recent search, fourteen women with the name Edith Carter have died in the last 22 years. The gambit ranges from a seamstress in a London suburb to a schoolteacher in Texas. Information about the artist is however immaterial to this story.]

Without calling the fashion-police it may appear to the casual viewer that the garb in which these women are portrayed is much too modern for the mid-19^th century, but as readers let’s chalk-up Carter’s choice to artist license.

Ann Foster (right) married John Melton in 1859. Her husband was a farmer and a Confederate soldier who took part in the Battle of Gettysburg. Laura Foster was her cousin.

Thomas Dula was a neighbor and close friend of Melton and served with Melton in the 42^nd North Carolina Infantry that participated with the Confederate Army at Gettysburg. Thomas and John were captured by Union Forces, but when the war ended in April 1865, they were released, and both returned to their farms in Wilks County in the northwestern corner of North Carolina.

Tom was a 20-something young man when he returned home from his Civil War service. He soon struck a relationship with Laura Foster. Tom had known the Foster cousins since he was twelve years old. Family legend takes a hard turn when in May 1866 it was discovered that Laura was pregnant, and the young couple planned to elope. On the morning of the 25^th, Laura left her home and was never seen alive again.

The gossip and rumors started immediately. The cousins blamed each other, the accused was said to have exacted revenge for contracting “the pock” (syphilis) and where no truth was common knowledge, people made false claims for and against everyone involved. Including the local doctor.

Dula was the one who ultimately paid the price for deeds-most-foul. He was tried (twice), found guilty (twice), and hanged for the crime. In an account of his life, that he wrote (or told to a scribe) while in prison, he claimed that he, “. . . did not harm a single hair on that fair lady’s head,” a remark that he repeated as he stood on the gallows on May 1, 1868.

It was Dula’s younger sister who retrieved his body and buried him at the Tom Dula Grave Site along State Highway 1134 (Tom Dula Road), a mile from the intersection of State Highway 268, near Ferguson, Wilkes County, North Carolina.

Dula’s family name was pronounced by most in the area with a long A, thus he was known as Tom “Dew’ Lay.” Nearly a hundred years later and six decades into the 20th century a folk song entitled The Legend of Tom Dooley, was written based on the otherworldly happenings that surrounded the murder of Laura Foster.

The murder of Laura Foster is a cold case, but many mythical tales are still told. One of which is that Anne Melton confessed in a death-bed statement that she killed her cousin in a state of jealousy over her relationship with Tom, but never felt guilt because she had suffered a life of personal torment over her sin of killing Laura and begging Tom into helping her hide Laura’s body.